Codex in Github Not Reviewing PRs

After adding Codex to my GitHub repo, granting it permission to review all repos, and submitting a PR, I’m not seeing where Codex is automatically review my PRs as advertised. Upon submitting a comment in the discussion section (@codex review), I get the following error: “To use Codex here, create a Codex account and connect to github.”

I have a ChatGPT Plus account and I’ve been able to use Codex locally via the IDE extension.

Anyone knows how to resolve this issue?

3 Likes

Hi and welcome to the community!

This is a strange error message because as of today there are no separate codex accounts. Instead Codex can be used with an API key or a ChatGPT subscription.
Can you confirm that you are using OpenAI Codex and not a third party app with a confusingly similar name?

2 Likes

We are in agreement that it is strange. However, it is the right extension that is integrated in GitHub.

When I click on the link, it takes me to the official ChatGPT Codex site (the forum is blocking me from posting links).

1 Like

3 Likes

Indeed this looks interesting.
I will ping staff to get some clarification.

Unfortunately, in the meantime I have no better suggestion than to turn it off and back on again uninstall and reinstall the GitHub app.

1 Like

:smiley: Good suggestion. I’ve tried that and it yielded the same results, I’m afraid. Definitely hoping you guys solve this soon so I can look into cancelling my Cursor Bugbot subscription lol

2 Likes

I learned that pinging @ codex will actually work when the ChatGPT account is connected to the GitHub account. This needs to be done from inside ChatGPT → Settings → Connectors

The team also updated the description of the codex organization on GitHub. This organization is separate from the OpenAI organization and exists only to allow pinging @ codex on GitHub.

I hope this helps!

1 Like

I had already connected My GitHub account to my ChatGPT account.

I tried disconnecting my GitHub account and then reconnecting it and that worked!

2 Likes

Great!
On my side I noted a prompt to confirm additional permissions required by the app. Most likely because I connected it shortly after the Codex GitHub app was released and there have been feature upgrades in the meantime.

1 Like

i have the same issue

in Code Review settings its telling me

Action required
Some repos require updated GitHub permissions for code reviews to work

so i click the “Update” button which takes me to the github install page, and there everythign is set properly (it has access to my repo)

however as many times as i save and confirm this, mentioning @codex doesnt work in a PR (i get the same message back as OP)

some more context: this used to work for me but then it just stopped one day

1 Like