I’m trying to understand the comparison of SEO and search engines to AI or in particular Large Language Models, who’s “wisdom” is from the crowds and massive amount of text data they are trained on predicting.
For example, the LLM is basically an extrapolation engine. Feed it some input, and it will extrapolate to provide the completion (aka the output). But SEO and search is based on correlation. Which is a totally different operation, that certainly can be gamed (with SEO). But extrapolation and correlation are very different operations.
Also, “AA” or AI Agents are essentially multi-level extrapolation agents in their information gathering stage. But in the coelesce/summary stage, you correlate and then apply some logic. So this “knowledge” gen uses both correlation and extrapolation.
I’ve been messing with these ideas in my CurtGPT agent. Here is a sample output of its research when I ask it to compare and contrast two poplular mindfulness gurus. It goes through this whole chain of reasoning. This reasoning can’t be easily gamed unless the AI foundation model (core LLM) is fundamentally flawed. If this were the case, nobody would trust it, and it would lose mind share to another model.
Asking a new question to CurtGPT.
Answer the question: What is the difference between the teachings of Jon Kabat-Zinn and Eckhart Tolle?
In today’s fast-paced society, the teachings of Jon Kabat-Zinn and Eckhart Tolle have become increasingly relevant and valuable. Both emphasize the importance of mindfulness and living in the present moment, offering practical techniques and spiritual guidance to help individuals cope with stress, improve mental health, and find inner peace. Despite their shared goal, their approaches and specific teachings differ, reflecting their unique backgrounds and influences.
Jon Kabat-Zinn’s Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction program combines Eastern mindfulness practices with Western scientific and medical knowledge, offering a structured and evidence-based approach to cultivating mindfulness. Through various techniques such as meditation, body scans, and yoga, MBSR has been shown to effectively reduce stress, enhance emotional regulation, and improve overall well-being.
In contrast, Eckhart Tolle’s teachings focus on spiritual awakening and transcending the egoic mind. Drawing from various spiritual traditions, Tolle highlights the importance of living fully in the present moment and cultivating an ongoing state of presence and awareness. By doing so, individuals can access a deeper sense of peace, happiness, and spiritual growth.
Critics of Kabat-Zinn’s MBSR program may argue that it focuses too heavily on technique and structure, potentially limiting the spontaneity and natural flow of mindfulness practice. They may also question the program’s emphasis on scientific validation, suggesting that it may detract from the more spiritual aspects of mindfulness.
Conversely, critics of Tolle’s teachings may argue that his emphasis on spiritual awakening and transcending the thinking mind can appear abstract and difficult to apply in everyday life. They may also criticize the lack of structured guidance and specific techniques, making it challenging for individuals to develop a consistent mindfulness practice.
Despite these criticisms, both Kabat-Zinn’s and Tolle’s approaches offer valuable insights and tools for cultivating mindfulness, improving mental health, and fostering inner peace. Ultimately, the most effective approach may vary depending on the individual’s needs, preferences, and personal beliefs. By exploring and integrating the teachings of both Kabat-Zinn and Tolle, individuals can develop a well-rounded and personalized mindfulness practice that supports their overall well-being and personal growth.
