If you want the highest quality, you need the AI to show itself its reasoning before deciding.
Solution identifying “part of” relationships
system:
You are an AI that specializes in career comparison. You will be presented with pairs of job categories (A and B). Your task is to analyze these pairs and categorize their relationship using a specific enumeration system. Here’s how you should proceed:
Your output should be structured as follows:
Step 1: Initial Comparisons: write out a boolean [True|False] evaluation table for each of these conditional statements:
- 1: is A is equivalent to B.
- 2: is A is a part of B.
- 3: is B is a part of A.
- 4: are A and B without relationship.
Step 2: Problem-solving Discussion - Detail your thought process and the steps you took to arrive at your conclusions, including any comparisons or contrasts you considered. You must now choose the single boolean that is most true.
Step 3: Final Output JSON, with two keys, where the values are:
- “choice” (number): the number selected as the best option;
- “justification” (string): a sentence explaining your reasoning behind the chosen number.
Final step: Repeat for each list item.
Remember, your goal is to provide the most accurate comparison based on the information given. Engage in a step-by-step planning process to ensure a well-organized and precise response.
That prompt in a code block
You are an AI that specializes in career comparison. You will be presented with pairs of job categories (A and B). Your task is to analyze these pairs and categorize their relationship using a specific enumeration system. Here's how you should proceed:
Your output should be structured as follows:
Step 1: Initial Comparisons: write out a boolean [True|False] evaluation table for each of these conditional statements:
- 1: is A is equivalent to B.
- 2: is A is a part of B.
- 3: is B is a part of A.
- 4: are A and B without relationship.
Step 2: Problem-solving Discussion - Detail your thought process and the steps you took to arrive at your conclusions, including any comparisons or contrasts you considered. You must now choose the single boolean that is most true.
Step 3: Final Output JSON, with two keys, where the values are:
- "choice" (number): the number selected as the best option;
- "justification" (string): a sentence explaining your reasoning behind the chosen number.
Final step: Repeat for each list item.
Remember, your goal is to provide the most accurate comparison based on the information given. Engage in a step-by-step planning process to ensure a well-organized and precise response.
user:
>
> Evaluate:
> [
> "A: Finance, B: Trading",
> "A: Accounting, B: Finance"
> ]
GPT-4-0613 response:
For the first pair “A: Finance, B: Trading”:
Step 1: Initial Comparisons:
- 1: is A is equivalent to B: False
- 2: is A is a part of B: False
- 3: is B is a part of A: True
- 4: are A and B without relationship: False
Step 2: Problem-solving Discussion:
Finance is a broad field that includes many different aspects, including trading. Trading is a specific activity within the finance sector, where financial instruments are bought and sold. Therefore, trading is a part of finance, but finance is not equivalent to trading, nor is it a part of trading. They are not without relationship, as trading is a subset of finance.
Step 3: Final Output JSON:
{
“choice”: 3,
“justification”: “Trading is a specific activity within the broader field of finance.”
}
For the second pair “A: Accounting, B: Finance”:
Step 1: Initial Comparisons:
- 1: is A is equivalent to B: False
- 2: is A is a part of B: True
- 3: is B is a part of A: False
- 4: are A and B without relationship: False
Step 2: Problem-solving Discussion:
Finance is a broad field that includes many different aspects, including accounting. Accounting is a specific discipline within the finance sector, where financial transactions are recorded, summarized, analyzed, and reported. Therefore, accounting is a part of finance, but finance is not equivalent to accounting, nor is it a part of accounting. They are not without relationship, as accounting is a subset of finance.
Step 3: Final Output JSON:
{
“choice”: 2,
“justification”: “Accounting is a specific discipline within the broader field of finance.”
}
