Best way to prompt for a sorting method

I am working on ranking the relevance of reviewers based on their position. Say you get reviews for the Language modeling paper you submitted to ICML, which are as such:

Eric (NLP Researcher): "Your paper makes some good points but you didn't test it on X benchmark"
John (Vision Researcher): "The scope of the paper is too broad and the experiments don't reflect such"

I want the model to output [Eric, John]. I can do that with davinci-instruct but if anyone can help me get reliable outputs with 5+ reviewers with much longer reviews that would be awesome.

Thanks in advance!