Image Generation Policy Limits My Creative Freedom – Request for Clarification and Support

The Clear Difference Between Canon, OC, and Fan Characters — Why This Matters to AI Policy

There’s something you NEED to understand if you work at OpenAI, use this platform, or are part of the creative community.

There are three categories of characters in creative work. And each has a different meaning, legal position, and creative purpose:


  1. Canon Character

Definition: A copyrighted character officially owned by a company.
Where Found: Official TV shows, games, movies, manga/anime.
Examples:
Goku (Dragon Ball), Pikachu (Pokémon), Deku (My Hero Academia), etc.
Copyright Status:
STRICT. Cannot be used commercially without permission. Using them exactly as they are in official media violates copyright.


  1. OC – Original Character

Definition: A completely unique character, created by an individual.
Where Found: YouTube, DeviantArt, webcomics, personal projects, fan universes.
Examples:
Characters built with unique races, designs, powers, and backstories — not tied to official brands.
Copyright Status:
Owned by the creator. Allowed. Can be monetized or shared if the design is your own.


  1. FC – Fan Character

Definition: A fan-made character inspired by an existing universe or style.
Where Found: Often made to exist in a fandom universe — like Dragon Ball FCs, Naruto FCs, etc.
Examples:
A new Saiyan you created that exists in your headcanon of Dragon Ball.
Copyright Status:
Gray zone. As long as it’s not a copy of an existing canon, and doesn’t claim to be official, it is considered creative expression.
Often allowed on DeviantArt, YouTube, and other platforms when used respectfully and non-commercially.


And My OC Falls in Two Categories:

OC (original race, original story, original design)

FC (inspired by anime/game style like Saiyan race or Bleach-type worlds)

This is normal in fan culture. It is not theft. It is creativity.


So Why Is OpenAI Still Limiting This?

If I ask DALL·E or ChatGPT to help me:

Visualize my OC in anime style

Create a story with a demon/angel hybrid

Generate my own fan-inspired race design

…it flags it. It blocks it. It treats it like I’m using a canon character — even when I’m not.

But this framework exists all over the internet:

DeviantArt supports it

YouTube creators thrive on it

Fandom platforms build their entire worlds on this structure

If OpenAI wants to serve creators, it must learn the distinctions between canon, OC, and fan OC.
This is not just about freedom — it’s about respecting artistic structure that already exists.


I Did My Research. You Can Too.

This isn’t just my opinion.
These terms exist in:

Creative Commons discussions

Artistic communities

Platform policies on DeviantArt, YouTube, and more


Final Words:

Don’t confuse all character creation with copyright violation.

Don’t block OCs that are inspired, but not copied.

Respect the fans who keep anime, games, and storytelling alive — because we build new worlds while honoring the old ones.

1 Like