Response from API call to fine tuned model not as expected

I have an API call set up to format text which I have fine tuned with ~60 lines of data, although, the responses I’m getting are worse than they are if I don’t fine tune and just have an API call directly to gpt4.

The formatting I’ve specified in my prompt(s) is pretty straight forward and clear, and I’ve broken these formatting down with instruction and example tags… Does anyone have any insight as to why this could be/can anyone help?

Thanks in advance!