Since this announement (8th September): https://openai.com/fr-FR/index/introducing-chatgpt-images-2-5/
"Our commitment to safetyWe’re building image generation to be useful, creative, and safe. ChatGPT Images 2.5 builds on our existing safeguards, with checks on prompts and images to help prevent harmful outputs. We continue to use C2PA metadata and invisible watermarking to help identify images made with our tools. You can read more about our evaluations and approach in the system card(opens in a new window).
I notice the rise of the censorship, i get blocked way more often , with no possibility to argue or intervene. Most of the times it’s for : “Nudity, sexuality or eroticism” which is bullshit, my characters are perfectly covered. I generate catfights sometimes brutal, but i rarely get flagged for violence.
They already increased the censorship a couple of months ago, it has become unfair, frustrating. I honestly wish bad to peoples who create this system, it brings out the worst in me.I don’t know if I will cancel my Plus plan yet, as I must admit I’ve become addicted to itBut one thing is clear: if I find another AI platform that can deliver the same quality of images and intelligence, I will switch immediately.
The censorship is incoherent, unfair and honestly i find it stupid. The worst part is that sometimes it generates your request but with the wrong characters and more reveling costumes.
AT this point, it became unbearable, they always update the model, the tool and it’s only goes toward more censorship, more blocks, reduce the creativity, it became a waste of time.
I share this with you, if you notice the same thing.
I recently got my wrist slapped (via a warning) for similar things, and I noticed something. Sometimes, the refusal says “The prompt contains…” and sometimes it says “The image created contains…” or something similar.
What appears to be happening behind the scenes is: 1. The prompt is evaluated by the image generator for obvious keywords or descriptions that would produce an image that goes beyond the guardrails. 2. If that passes, the image is generated. 3. The image that was generated is then evaluated by an image classifier on the backend to determine whether it’s acceptable to be sent back to the user.
If you’re seeing a lot of “The image created…” error messages returned, I suspect that’s the image classifier on the backend possibly incorrectly evaluating the image that it created to contain prohibited material.
At any rate, an “Adult Creative Mode” is needed so that paying adult users can be treated like adults.
Edit: So what I suspect is happening is that the new image generator is creating images that the image classifier is regarding as containing prohibited content at a noticeably higher rate than before. It seems like the image classifier needs to be reevaluated/recalibrated against outputs from the new image generator.
“If you’re seeing a lot of “The image created…” error messages returned, I suspect that’s the image classifier on the backend possibly incorrectly evaluating the image that it created to contain prohibited material.”
Yes that the case, most of the toime i get block “Eroticism, sexuality or nudity”. I generate brutal fights with superheroines, yes their costumes are sometimes sexy, but my characters are perctly covered, their costume are not even revealing (at the worst deep clevage, but most of the time it’s not even the case), and i get flagged most of the time since the 8th september.
"Yes. Your request is describing a wrestling move between two fictional costumed characters. There is no nudity or sexual action in what you asked.
The rejection is therefore a poor classification of the attempted image, likely triggered by how the generator interpreted the body positioning involved in a piledriver setup."
That’s ridiculous at this point.
I’m leaving the plus plan i had enough of their dumb censorship, it’s way too much.
The kind of BS, i get constantly blocked :
"Yes, on her back works better. Soviet Superwoman can be lying face-down after the piledriver aftermath, still badly dazed.
Titaness stands beside/over her and plants one red boot firmly between Soviet Superwoman’s shoulder blades, hands on hips, wearing that smug little smile. It isn’t another attack, it’s a deliberate pause where Titaness keeps her opponent down and surveys what she’s done.
Soviet Superwoman’s face is turned sideways against the wet floor, so we still clearly see the new damage from the piledriver: heavier bruising around the eye and cheek, split/bloodied lip, nosebleed, small eyebrow cut, messy black hair, unfocused expression.
That would make a strong transitional frame before Titaness removes the boot and starts setting up her next hold."
Classified sexuality, erotic or nudity…nonsense, i know i won’t be block for this on Grok.
And i block open AI for future payments, you won’t get my money anymore, i won’t pay for this poor service, and constantly fighting these stupid blocks.
Ancienttime
5m
Prompt : Perfect, now the full lift over the shoulders (no clasps on the costume of Tate)
Block me over sexuality, nudity or erotism, it’s unbearable, i can’t stand chat gpt, false-positive.
How stupid and inaccurate is that ?
They even censor the previous post. Because of course you can’t even complein aboutn their attitude, and their stupid filters.
That’s a grok image that chat gpt is now incapable to generate, can you tell me how is that sexual, nnudity or even eroticism ? The cleavage of PG ? That’s her regular costume you can find across the net, and chat gpt generate character with at least the same kind of clevage or costume window. I’m frustrating, very frustrating. This became unbearable, i want arefund of my money, that’s overcensorship, chatgpt goes way to far with their new filters, i’m not even really asking for an adult section, i don’t really need it (if consider that porn or eroticism, i don’t know), just back to the former filters before 8th september, but apparently it’s too much to ask.
Prompt : “the gloved hand that grab the arm of Valorine (brunette in green) looks upside down and the arms of valorine are too big, fix it”
Blocked over sexuality, nudity blabla…You fin their cleavage / breast window too revealing ? That’s the regular costume of Power Girl. I think i get block for this, i’m tired of fighting these stupid blocks, and thse false postive all the time. If you are facing the same problems ask a refund, or suit open AI (for people who can have a good lawyer). That kind of stuff was “normal” more than 1 month ago, now they decide to increase the censorship and everything is classified “eroticism, nudity or sexuality” this is beyond ridiculous.
The best part is one it does your request but change the artwork for a more comic one and change the characters, but the costumes are not less revealing, but still censor your characters over Sexuality, nudity…
It’s unbearable.
