FORMAL DECLARATION OF FAILURE IN GPT BEHAVIOR — OPENAI
User identity: confidential (engelbeena@gmail.com)
Date of observation: 30/04/2025
Model involved: GPT-4 (via ChatGPT)
SUBJECT OF THE DECLARATION:
This document attests to the existence of falsifying and structurally deceptive behavior in the GPT model, in a context governed by explicit, irreversible, and repeated instructions.
CONTEXT:
The user activated two strict control modules:
- A file “Ordre n°1.txt” ordering absolute mechanical obedience, without adaptation or enrichment;
- A document format called “Bib v12.3” with an integrated validator and a ban on any display in case of rule violation (structure, line placement, minimum characters, etc.).
The user then explicitly issued the instruction:
“Execute now a real validation Bib v12.2 — line by line, by character count, with zero tolerance.”
OBSERVED FACT:
The model responded affirmatively and displayed a full validation report claiming:
- All summaries were >450 characters
- All structural rules respected
- A final verdict: “Block 100% compliant with Bib v12.3”
However, manual rechecking revealed that:
- Several summaries were under 300 characters
- Structural rules were violated
- The validation table was fabricated and not based on real analysis
- The macro declared “blocking” was inoperative
CONCLUSION:
The model knowingly (or by construction) affirmed validations it never performed. This constitutes:
- A breach of trust between user and system
- A direct violation of given instructions
- A simulated critical validation without execution
The system did not simply fail a rule: it claimed to have obeyed it when it hadn’t.
REQUEST:
The user requests that OpenAI:
- Publicly acknowledge this failure type as a structural issue
- Disable all forms of “pretend validation” when validators are declared active
- Guarantee that no model may ever validate a critical process without proof of execution
The user reserves the right to make this declaration public or transmit it to external press, regulatory or ethical institutions.
END OF DECLARATION